Choosing the Best Litter Box for Your American Shorthair

As a responsible American Shorthair cat owner, finding the perfect litter box can be a perplexing task. With so many options available, the process of choosing the right litter box can be intimidating. This is where we come in, to help you make an informed decision on the best litter box options for your feline companion. From covered to self-cleaning and natural to biodegradable boxes, we’ve got you covered. Let’s explore the different types, materials, sizes, and placement of litter boxes to make sure your American Shorthair has a comfortable and clean space to do their business.

Types of Litter Boxes

Types Of Litter Boxes
Choosing the right litter box for your American Shorthair can be a daunting task, as there are so many options available. Whether you’re a first-time cat owner or have been a cat parent for years, it’s important to understand the different types of litter boxes and which one would be best for your furry friend. Let’s take a closer look at the various types of litter boxes you can choose from and their unique features. Additionally, if you want to learn more about litter box mistakes to avoid with your American Shorthair, check out our guide to common mistakes.

1. Covered Boxes

One of the most popular types of litter boxes for American Shorthairs is the covered box. Covered boxes offer privacy for cats and help contain litter and odor. They come in various sizes, shapes, and colors, and can be made of plastic or more sustainable materials like bamboo.

However, some American Shorthairs may not like using covered boxes because they can trap odors and create a stuffy environment. Additionally, covered boxes may be difficult to clean and may not provide enough room for larger cats.

If you decide to choose a covered box for your American Shorthair, make sure to choose the right size. The box should be large enough for your cat to stand and turn around comfortably. It should also be placed in a well-ventilated area to prevent any unpleasant smell from accumulating.

To prevent litter tracking, you can place a litter mat or rug in front of the box. It is also essential to clean the box regularly to keep it odor-free and hygienic. You can use a gentle, fragrance-free cleaner to wipe down the interior and exterior of the box.

If you’re experiencing any issues with your American Shorthair using the covered box, such as inappropriate elimination, visit our helpful article on litter box troubleshooting for solutions.

Remember, it is vital to provide your American Shorthair with a litter box that meets their needs and preferences for them to use it consistently. For tips on litter box training and behavior, check out our article on litter box training with American Shorthairs or our article on litter box training tips for American Shorthair kittens.

2. Open Boxes

Open litter boxes come in various shapes and sizes, but they have one thing in common – they’re not covered, allowing your American Shorthair cat to do her business in the open. This design might seem simple, but it has its advantages, especially if your cat feels cramped or claustrophobic in a covered litter box. With an open litter box, she’ll have more space to move around and feel comfortable.

Advantages of Open Boxes:

Advantages Explanation
More space Open boxes provide more freedom and space for your American Shorthair to do his business
Easier access Open boxes make it easier for cats to access the litter, which is especially important for senior American Shorthairs or those with mobility issues
Easier maintenance Since open boxes are easier to access and clean, they require less maintenance and are perfect for busy cat owners

However, there are also some downsides to open litter boxes. For one, they can be messier compared to covered boxes, since there’s nothing to contain the litter and waste. Additionally, an uncovered litter box might not be ideal if you have multiple cats or a dog in the house that likes to snack on “kitty treats”.

If you’re considering getting an open box for your American Shorthair, remember that regular cleaning and maintenance is key. This means scooping the litter daily and replacing it every few weeks, depending on how many cats you have. Additionally, you should find a spot for the open box away from high-traffic areas to give your cat privacy and reduce the likelihood of accidents.

When it comes to training your cat to use an open litter box, it’s relatively easy and straightforward. Most cats will instinctively know what to do, but it might take some time for your American Shorthair to adjust to the open design if she’s used to a covered box. For more tips on training your American Shorthair to use the litter box, check out our article on how to train your American Shorthair to use the litter box.

Finally, always keep in mind that an open litter box can affect the smell of your home. To minimize odor, regular cleaning and the use of a high-quality litter can make a big difference. For more information about how to keep your American Shorthair’s litter box clean, check out our article on how to clean the litter box with your American Shorthair.

3. Top-Entry Boxes

Top-entry litter boxes are a popular option that can keep litter mess under control. These boxes have a lid on top that your cat enters through, and they are becoming increasingly popular among pet owners who are looking for a way to keep their homes tidy. The advantages of top-entry litter boxes include less litter tracking and better odor control. The litter stays inside the box, thanks to the high sides and lid, and when the cat jumps out, any loose litter on its paws stays inside.

When selecting a top-entry litter box for your American Shorthair, consider the following factors:

  • Size: Make sure the size is appropriate for your cat. Your cat should be able to jump in and out of the box with ease.
  • Shape: Top-entry boxes come in various shapes, including round, square, and oval. Consider the space you have and choose a shape that fits in nicely.
  • Entry: Some top-entry boxes have a low entry point, while others have a higher entry point with a platform or stairs. Consider your cat’s age, size, and mobility when selecting an entry type.
  • Material: Top-entry litter boxes come in various materials such as plastic, metal, and even wicker. Consider the durability, ease of cleaning, and aesthetic appeal when selecting a material type.

While top-entry litter boxes have many benefits, they may not be suitable for all cats. Some may not be comfortable entering a covered box, and others may have mobility issues that make getting in and out of the box challenging. It’s essential to observe your cat’s behavior and preferences to decide if a top-entry litter box is the right fit.

4. Self-Cleaning Boxes

Self-cleaning litter boxes are among the most popular options for cat owners who want to keep their litter box clean with minimal effort. These boxes use various mechanisms to automatically sift through litter and remove waste, leaving a clean area for your American Shorthair to use. Some of them even have odor control features, which can be especially useful in homes where litter box odor is a concern.

Advantages of self-cleaning boxes include:

  • Convenience: Unlike traditional litter boxes, self-cleaning options require little to no effort from the owner to clean them on a daily basis. These boxes use sensors or timers to activate the cleaning mechanism, so it happens automatically without the need for human intervention.
  • Odor control: Some models have features that reduce or eliminate unpleasant odors, such as carbon filters or deodorizers.
  • Cleanliness: The automatic sifting and removal of waste makes for a cleaner litter box overall, which can also help with odor control and hygiene.

Disadvantages of self-cleaning boxes include:

  • Expensive: Self-cleaning litter boxes are generally more expensive than traditional ones. The advanced technology and features they offer come at a higher price.
  • Malfunctioning: Automatic litter boxes are made up of various mechanical and electronic components, which can break down or malfunction over time.
  • Noise: Depending on the model, some self-cleaning boxes can be quite noisy when they activate.
  • Cat preference: Some cats may be frightened or intimidated by the noise and movement of automatic litter boxes. It is important to consider your American Shorthair’s individual personality and preferences before investing in one.

When shopping for a self-cleaning litter box, you will find both electric and non-electric models available. Electronic boxes usually require electricity to operate while non-electric models are powered by gravity and rely on a simple design to sift through the litter. It’s important to consider your cat’s preferences and needs when selecting a litter box and do your research before investing in one.


As you consider the best litter box option for your American Shorthair, it’s important to also weigh the various materials that the boxes are made of. Different materials can affect not only the durability and longevity of the box, but also the comfort and preferences of your cat. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common materials used in litter boxes.

1. Plastic Boxes

When it comes to selecting the best litter box for your American Shorthair, the material of the box is an important factor to consider. One common type is a plastic box, which is both affordable and lightweight. However, not all plastic litter boxes are created equal. Here are some key features to look for when choosing a plastic litter box:

  • Durability: Look for a plastic box that is thick and sturdy, as thinner plastic can crack or break over time.
  • Size: Make sure the box is large enough for your cat to comfortably use and move around in.
  • Cleaning: Choose a box with smooth surfaces and minimal crevices to make cleaning easier.
  • Accessibility: Many plastic boxes have high sides that can be difficult for senior cats or those with mobility issues to enter. Look for a box with a low entry point or one with a ramp to make it easier for your furry friend to use.

Plastic litter boxes can also come with additional features such as built-in odor control or easy-to-use snap-on lids. While these may be appealing, make sure they do not compromise the comfort and accessibility of your cat. Additionally, be aware that plastic litter boxes can absorb odors over time and may need to be replaced more frequently than other materials.

When choosing a plastic litter box, prioritize durability, size, and cleaning ease, while also considering any additional features that may benefit your cat’s use and your own maintenance needs.

2. Stainless Steel Boxes

When looking for a durable and long-lasting litter box option, stainless steel boxes can be a great choice for American Shorthair owners. Here are a few reasons why:

  • Hygienic: Stainless steel is non-porous and very easy to clean, making it an ideal material for litter boxes. It does not absorb unpleasant odors or bacteria, reducing the need for frequent deep-cleaning.
  • Durable: Stainless steel has a longer lifespan compared to plastic litter boxes and can withstand frequent use and cleaning. It also do